×
Convivium was a project of Cardus 2011‑2022, and is preserved here for archival purposes.
Search
Search
The Core of the Euthanasia ClashThe Core of the Euthanasia Clash

The Core of the Euthanasia Clash

This week’s Supreme Court hearing on euthanasia was about life and death, of course, but it is equally about a powerful clash of institutions.

Peter Stockland
1 minute read

This week’s Supreme Court hearing on euthanasia was about life and death, of course, but it is equally about a powerful clash of institutions.

While the so-called Carter case was argued on the merits of discovering in the Canadian constitution a right to what might be called concierge service suicide, the heart of the discussion was really the balance of power between the courts and Canada’s Parliament.

All constitutional cases, by their nature, engage that balance in differing ways, particularly when they involve the sections of the Charter of Rights dealing with security of the person and equality rights. Yet Wednesday’s forensic test match on euthanasia touched a tipping point that may have been brushed against only 26 years ago in the Morgentaler case on abortion; perhaps not even then.

At least two elements make the Carter case so noteworthy in that regard.

Read more: http://www.cardus.ca/blog/2014/10/the-core-of-the-euthanasia-clash

You'll also enjoy...

Free Not To Speak

Free Not To Speak

Its purpose is to launch more legal challenges on purely business grounds to the Canada Summer Jobs attestation requirement, and to raise awareness of what spokesperson Tamara Jansen called “shocking overreach” by the federal government “Similarly, the right to freedom of thought, belief and opinion...

The Core of the Euthanasia Clash

The Core of the Euthanasia Clash

He said the trial judge made a political, not a judicial decision when she ruled that the risks of striking down the Canada's current euthanasia and assisted suicide laws were worth taking While the so-called Carter case was argued on the merits of discovering in the Canadian constitution a right to...

Simply About Freedom

Simply About Freedom

In the past two weeks, Ottawa lawyer Albertos Polizogopoulos has argued the case for conscience rights of doctors, and won a major freedom of information legal battle over publicizing statistics about abortion. Convivium Publisher Peter Stockland sat down with him to discuss the cases.