Unwrapping Jagmeet SinghUnwrapping Jagmeet Singh

Unwrapping Jagmeet Singh

Father Raymond de Souza finds the NDP leader a fascinatingly odd fit for the identity politics of a left-wing party because of the very diversity that makes up Mr. Singh.

Raymond J. de Souza
4 minute read
Like Convivium? , our free weekly email newsletter.

Jagmeet Singh is a many-splendoured phenomenon, and I don’t just mean his $2000 bespoke suits and Rolex watches. I find him fascinating, and his rise should be fascinating for those concerned about the place of religion in our common life.

His new television ads emphasize his identity, which is fitting for an age when identity politics dominates the left. But what is that identity? Are his fashionable turbans-of-many-colours a matter of culture or religion? 

Jagmeet – does anyone ever call him Mr. Singh? – is the son of Sikh immigrants to Canada, but did not grow up in an area of heavy Sikh settlement, like Brampton or Vancouver. He would move to those places and run for office there. But he grew up in Newfoundland and Windsor. In Windsor, he relates that he was subject to racial slurs on the playground. That’s not outside the common experience of Indo-Canadians of his age, but the Singh family solution certainly was. They sent him across the border to an elite American private school, Detroit County Day School; where the annual tuition sets you back $30,000. Jagmeet went on to do what a lot of rich sons of doctors do, going to Osgoode Hall Law School and then into politics.

His story represents another chapter in Canada’s immigrant story, the son of affluent parents who grew up in privilege. It’s a happy story – that Singh’s parents could do so well in Canada having arrived with little – but challenges the idea that all sons of immigrants grew up in economic straits. Jagmeet may not have been as rich as Justin Trudeau, but neither had the comfortable middle-class upbringing of, say, Andrew Scheer.

It’s one of those unexpected anomalies, that Canada’s first racial minority federal party leader went to a school for rich kids in the United States. But politics is like that. Who would have thought that America’s first black president would be raised by his white mother and white grandparents, his African father having skipped out on the family? That’s the tricky thing about identity politics; identities are complex and people don’t come in neat little boxes.

Which makes Singh’s first campaign ad so fascinating. The French-language one begins with Jagmeet without his turban, his vast mane putting to shame former Pittsburgh Steeler star Troy Polamalu’s shampoo commercials. Then he wraps his turban as his voiceover states that he is proud of his identity, “as you are.” The next shot is of Jagmeet wrapping again, but this time his fists for boxing gloves as he works the heavy bag before a little martial arts grappling in the ring. 

Well, it worked for Justin Trudeau. Perhaps it’s a rich-kid thing, though even if he had grown up rich it would be hard to imagine Scheer working the heavy bag. Anyway, the slogan is that the NDP will “fight for you,” so perhaps that’s the reason for the pugilist theme. 

Identities are complex, no? The squared circle and the studied adoption of a Savile Row wardrobe don’t usually go together, but in Jagmeet they do. For that matter, a fuchsia turban does not usually accessorize Savile Row, but Jagmeet does it.

So what then of his religious identity? Being Sikh is both an ethnicity – it’s not really a race – and a religion, not unlike, I suppose, being Jewish. But the turban and the kirpan – both of which Singh wears – are religious practices. So, when Jagmeet presents himself to Canadians tying his turban and professing pride in his identity, is he presenting his religious identity or a cultural one, or is it simply the reality that the two cannot be separated?

If the latter, it raises an interesting question for our common life, not least in Quebec. The consensus in that province is that cultural diversity is to be celebrated in the public sector workplace, but religious practices are to be confined to the private sphere at home. And while other provinces do not have Quebec’s laws on religious attire, the same dynamic is frequently at work, in both public and private workplaces, universities and schools. Culture is welcome and celebrated; religion is to be at bay, if not actively excluded. 

But which is which?

I don’t expect that Jagmeet intends to get into all that during the election campaign. The NDP he leads has fallen a long way from that of Christian clergymen Tommy Douglas and Bill Blaikie, and now seems positively allergic to the public contribution of religion and religious believers. It may be that the election ad was produced hoping to elicit a racist word from someone, anyone, that might allow the NDP to trumpet some righteous indignation. It wouldn’t be the first time that ploy has been tried. 

Over the next weeks we shall see what role, if any, Singh’s religion qua religion informs his campaign. Or will it be just ethnicity? Or a cultural mix? Or is he just a wrapper, who likes to bind both his hair and fists?

Convivium means living together. We welcome your voice to the conversation. Do you know someone who would enjoy this article? Send it to them now. Do you have a response to something we've published? Let us know!   

You'll also enjoy...

The Beam of Christian Schooling

The Beam of Christian Schooling

Attacking faith-based institutions for upholding codes of conduct ignores the Charter, violates the spirit of pluralism, and risks undermining religious freedom, argues lawyer Barry Bussey.

At Least Quebec Is Honest About It

At Least Quebec Is Honest About It

After two very difficult human rights complaints over the last 15 years, the OHRC finally required Christian Horizons to open caregiver positions to anyone regardless of their religion The leading questions in the OHRC consultation are trying to sell state enforcement of secularism in Ontario ...

Marking Time With Meaning

Marking Time With Meaning

Against the ephemera of a “trending” time, Father Raymond de Souza contrasts the enduring calendar of holy days.

Join Convivium

Convivium means living together. Unlike many digital magazines, we haven’t put up a digital paywall. We want to keep the conversation regarding faith in our common and public life as open as possible.

Get a weekly wrap up of the latest articles delivered right to your inbox.