Convivium was a project of Cardus 2011‑2022, and is preserved here for archival purposes.
The Upside-Down Moral EconomyThe Upside-Down Moral Economy

The Upside-Down Moral Economy

Toronto mayor Rob Ford promised to end the gravy train at city hall, but no one imagined a train wreck like this.

Phil Reinders
5 minute read

Editor's note: This piece was originally published on the blog of Phil Reinders: Squinch.net. Reinders is the senior pastor of Knox Presbyterian Church, Toronto, and author of Seeking God's Face (2010). Republished with permission.

Toronto mayor Rob Ford promised to end the gravy train at city hall, but no one imagined a train wreck like this.

It's been a scandal like nothing seen before in Toronto the good. There's a snickering snort in our noses and a condescending smirk on our faces as we speak of high-minded things of politics and corruption. But every time I've joined the choristers of ridicule (and I've been a choir boy way too many times recently), I'm confronted, held back by myself.

I like to talk about the Mayor doing the right thing but the reality is that most of the time, in the ease and luxury of my privacy, I can hardly bring myself to do the right thing.

I want to be a voice for the higher ground but with every new revelation, every titillating video leak, I find myself a rubbernecking voyeur.

I'd like to voice some righteous rage but mostly what comes is a sad lament. For the demons of addiction that shipwreck so many lives. For all the ways that power corrupts. For the public humiliation of Rob Ford. For his wife and kids. For the Mayor's stubborn foolishness and all the so-called friends and advisors who encourage him to cling to power instead of seek healing. For the easy judgmentalism, the smug self-righteousness in me. For all the times I hide and evade responsibility. For all the ways I silently perpetuate the very things I criticize.

In the midst of this giddy Rob Ford pile-on, I was confronted by the biblical text our church studied yesterday. The timing of this fifth beatitude within this week's political circus was astonishing.

"Blessed are the merciful," says Jesus, "for they will receive mercy."

Photo: Wikimedia Commons[/caption]

Seriously, Jesus. Mercy?

In the face of these words of Jesus, I can feel a resistance movement organizing. "What about justice? Where is the accountability? Isn't mercy a free pass when something has to change?"

I'm struck by how deeply we trust condemnation as the most effective means for seeking and motivating change. The desire for justice, honesty, transparency, and good government are right. Yet when those are threatened we resort to rejection and condemnation because we want no mistaking that what is happening is wrong. We use condemnation, ridicule, and harsh judgment as the means to insulate us from what is wrong and produce change in whoever is causing the problem, getting people to shape up through condemnation (really, now, has anyone been condemned into a better way of living?).

Think of the dynamic which condemnation kick-starts—it forces you into a defensive posture, encasing you in a protective emotional armour, cutting you off from the possibility of receiving mercy. Isn't this the very situation Rob Ford finds himself in? He's been so pugilistic in his demeanour, polarizing sides and demonizing others, insulating himself from others and protecting his position so closely. It's left him incapable of receiving mercy, unable to see the mercy being extended to him in a resignation or a leave from office. He is perceiving mercy as a threat instead of a gift.

As I've lived with this beatitude, I recalled how Jesus was criticized for the company he kept. And the company he mostly kept was the Rob Fords of his day: the loathed tax-collectors, the socially despised, the immoral, the outcast. He was merciful to people who didn't deserve it.

Mercy is not what Rob Ford deserves. He deserves to be lambasted for the divisive folly of his leadership. He deserves to be shown the door for demeaning the office of mayor and pissing all over the trust given through his election. He has earned all the jibes and jeering sent his way for the absolute fool he's made of himself.

But in the upside-down moral economy of Jesus, we don't get what we deserve. And so, "Blessed are the merciful . . ." And blessed are those who come alongside the despised, the outcast, the wretched, the foolish, and extend to them undeserved grace.

The really unnerving thing about this beatitude is that it's less about the recipient of mercy and more about the giver. The crazy truth Jesus is exposing is that we need to give mercy as much as we need to receive it. The giving of mercy to Rob Ford is the healing that might prevent us from finding ourselves one day in the same space Mayor Ford now inhabits.

But that's so tough, isn't it? Have you noticed how being merciful doesn't feel very moral? Come on, admit it—it feels really good to find some high ground, point fingers, and get all righteously angry. It's like some moral adrenaline gets mainlined in us. But mercy—well, I'm not always sure what it feels like but what it does is put you at the same level as those you point the finger at. That's just plain humbling. And that just may be mercy's healing.

Obviously there are so many important questions that need answering, like why is the Mayor partying with alleged gangsters? What is he doing in clandestine meetings with drug dealers? How can we trust a serial liar?

But another important question I'm taking away is: why am I so quick to judge, so wary of mercy's power to season justice?

So while I remain longing for so much better for Toronto, I'm praying mercy for the mayor.

Let me end with one of the best commentaries on this beatitude of Jesus, Portia's mercy speech in The Merchant of Venice:

The quality of mercy is not strained.
It droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven
Upon the place beneath. It is twice blessed:
It blesseth him that gives and him that takes.
'Tis mightiest in the mightiest. It becomes
The throned monarch better than his crown.
His scepter shows the force of temporal power,
The attribute to awe and majesty
Wherein doth sit the dread and fear of kings,
But mercy is above this sceptered sway.
It is enthroned in the hearts of kings.
It is an attribute to God himself.
And earthly power doth then show likest God's
When mercy seasons justice.

Therefore, Jew, Though justice be thy plea, consider this—
That in the course of justice none of us
Should see salvation. We do pray for mercy,
And that same prayer doth teach us all to render
The deeds of mercy. I have spoke thus much
To mitigate the justice of thy plea,
Which if thou follow, this strict court of Venice
Must needs give sentence 'gainst the merchant there.

You'll also enjoy...

The Fine Print Matters!

The Fine Print Matters!

All of this is a very circuitous way to get to Toronto Mayor Rob Ford and his current legal troubles Most of us feel like helpless spectators to this sorry spectacle, but it does remind us that the fine print, usually overlooked as inconsequential, is in fact important and should be taken seriously ...

After the Scrutiny, What Good Remains?

After the Scrutiny, What Good Remains?

Considerable ink has been spilled and breath expended over whether or not faith-based institutions (Loyola High School; Trinity Western University; Catholic schools in Ontario; all religious schools in Manitoba) should have any say regarding their students' sexual activities or their employees' off-...

The Repentance of Thieves and Murderers

The Repentance of Thieves and Murderers

The reason why Cubans in tandem shout "Viva la revolucion, Viva Fide!" (and more recently "Viva Raul") is that Fidel has consciously cultivated a cult of personality in which his history is equated with the history of the Cuban communist state ...