Convivium was a project of Cardus 2011‑2022, and is preserved here for archival purposes.
Kiwi COVID Containment Bears Bad FruitKiwi COVID Containment Bears Bad Fruit

Kiwi COVID Containment Bears Bad Fruit

New Zealand is feted for its pandemic lockdown, but Robert Joustra says the awkward truth of Auckland’s approach is it raises irrational fear even as we’re being fleeced economically.

Robert Joustra
3 minute read

Pandemic public policy is now a field unto itself, saturated with experts, desperately low on data, yet with dangerously high stakes, at least politically. 

Take the case of New Zealand. Here is a prime minister and a country that has done, according to the chattering classes, everything right. A serious, long term lockdown, early on, entirely stamped out the disease before it took root. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern was feted across the globe for her farsighted seriousness. New Zealand became the model for containment. 

But last week, despite over 100 days without any new cases, several new ones emerged. Conventional wisdom would suggest a moderate response. But this puts the lie to that wisdom: security is still one significant concern that will always outpace economic productivity. Medium to long range economic damage will never outpace short term but certain security concerns. As with so many things, we have been here before. 

In the early 20th century, idealists argued at length that the prospects of a real war breaking out between Great Britain and the new German Empire were virtually nil. Such a war, the pundits correctly pointed out, would be tantamount to economic suicide. The German and British industries were too intertwined, their contracts too internationalized, the trade too rich. War was unthinkable. Yet, it is precisely what we got. Security and insecurity are not perfectly rational, cost-benefit games, and even certain future economic loss can be preferable to uncertain present-day risks to life and limb. 

This was what I had in mind as I watched New Zealand spiral into panic again. With an international record any of us could envy, its largest city – Auckland – reentered a Stage 3 lockdown. Supermarkets were overrun with hysterical buyers, and Prime Minister Ardern held a midnight press conference. At that time, there were four cases in the entire country. Now, the Prime Minister has said she is delaying the parliamentary election to October 17.

States aren’t going away because security isn’t going away. We idealistically imagine that we will become rich, cosmopolitan, or globalist enough that the rickety, tired structures of the nation-state will soon be a piece of the archaic political past. But overnight, the American passport went from one of the most powerful documents in the world to nearly meaningless. It will rebound, to be sure, but no matter how much money or influence the Americans have – and it is an awful lot – even the poorest countries of the world are turning their tourist dollars away with a firm: “No thank you.” 

What does it mean for our own careful reopening of schools and businesses this fall? I think it means no matter how economically suicidal certain policies may appear, uncertain short-run security concerns – that we might get sick – may win the battle for hearts and minds. Pandemic policy is mob policy. 

The mystifying math has left many of us without a clear understanding of the extent of the risk. All we know for certain is that some will get sick. Some will die. Critics of widescale reopening point to a callous trade off in lives for GDP. We do, admittedly, make these trade-offs in politics, though we rarely talk about them as such. Thousands would be saved from accidents if we abandoned our cars. How many lives are lost from socially acceptable risks we don’t have to take?

Only now – too little, too late – are bureaucracies beginning to brace the public for the reality that new cases are coming this fall season. Holding the line on such policies will require a resolve, a relationship to data and long run concerns, that I am not sure the public has been well equipped for. What will happen when the first outbreak hits a high school? Or a kindergarten? Not if, when.

If New Zealand is our model, will four new cases spark panic buying, and the suspension of an election? It might. States aren’t going away because security isn’t going away. And in the hierarchy of mob policy, our bank accounts – no matter how we’ve idolized them - will always come second to a crisis of security. And security, alas, is not a perfectly rational master.

You'll also enjoy...

Stealth Fighter Fever

Stealth Fighter Fever

A full, public, foreign policy review, with Minister Ambrose's steady hand on procurement, could yet connect value to dollars, and hardware to vision Second, rebooting a major defense procurement right in time for a foreign policy review gives Conservatives a chance to not only tether value to dolla...

Picture Parliament Without Parties

Picture Parliament Without Parties

Peter Menzies argues the salvation of Canadian democracy lies in our two youngest political jurisdictions where consensus government, not leadership whip cracking, prevails.

Getting Ahead of the COVID-19 Curve

Getting Ahead of the COVID-19 Curve

Prime Minister Trudeau announced today that nothing “is off the table” regarding COVID-19. Peter Stockland says we must consider civil liberties before the Emergencies Act is declared.