Convivium was a project of Cardus 2011‑2022, and is preserved here for archival purposes.
Forgetting To Always RememberForgetting To Always Remember

Forgetting To Always Remember

Cardus Senior Researcher Peter Jon Mitchell reflects on modern western society's discomfort with death and grief and the role that memory, faith, and religious communities can serve in the experience of public mourning. 

Peter Jon Mitchell
3 minute read

There’s an old story sometimes shared during eulogies about an elderly women planning her funeral.

“Burry me with a fork,” she tells her minister.

“Yes, but may I ask why?” he inquires.

She explains that as a child, when the dishes were cleared from the table, the forks were occasionally left behind. She came to learn that when the forks remained on the table, a sweet dessert was to follow.

“Burry me with a fork because something better is coming.”

Modern western society is uncomfortable talking about death. This discomfort is on display in a recent survey by the Angus Reid Institute and Cardus aimed at exploring faith in Canada.

About 60 percent of Canadians believe in some form of life after death. There is no consensus on what form that existence takes.  About 55 percent believe actions in this life have consequences in the life to come, with 57 percent of Canadians professing belief in Heaven, and a minority of Canadians at 41 percent stating they believe in Hell.

The declining presence of religion in public life is surely a contributing factor in our inability to find common language around death in what is a community experience. This is a loss, as people are less certain about what is to follow.

Author and journalist Jonathan Kay makes this point in a recent column, noting that the once commonly held idea of an afterlife made grieving tolerable. Kay considers the wide range of public reactions to catastrophe in a secular age where God is no longer welcome at the public podium. He confides that after a recent loss in his own social circle, “I realized that I hadn’t the slightest idea how to talk to my children – or anyone – about death.” Kay is hardly alone.

In fact, this summer marks the 20th anniversary of Princess Diana’s death. Among the ocean of flowers that pressed against the sealed gates of Kensington Palace, mourners left accompanying notes and cards providing the equivalent of a core sample of the soul of the nation. Biblical scholar and former Anglican Bishop of Durham, N.T. Wright, summarized the sentiments as “a rich confusion of belief, half belief, sentiment, and superstition about the fate of the dead.”

Faced with death, religious communities embody a narrative of hope displayed through corporate rituals, and acts of support that are instinctual in compassionate communities. The presence of religious communities also matter beyond the moments of tragedy and public grief, Wright reminds us. Philosophers from Plato forward understood that what we believe about how death shapes how we live.

Despite the absence of a common narrative around death, we understand grief requires public expression. Yale theologian Miroslov Volf argues that Western culture is in a memory boom. Every tragedy is memorialized almost the instant it happens. Volf argues the obsession with erecting memorials is in part a response to our short memories amid the frenzied pace of consumer culture and twenty-four hour news cycles.

Volf writes: “We demand immediate memorials as outward symbols because the hold of memory on our inner lives is so tenuous.”  Another reason we so rapidly memorialize is our social consensus that remembering and more concisely, our continuous remembering is “our most basic obligation to do justice.”

Remembering is a matter of doing justice.

The rich confusion around death is evident, Wright argues, in that most people rarely consider how the variety of beliefs about life after death shape the various way people organize their lives.

Grief draws us to reflect on meaning. Kay reminds us of the common refrain, in the aftermath of tragedy, to love each other more.

“It’s sentimental and unsatisfying,” he writes. “But without God by our side, it’s the best we can do.”

Kay argues we find meaning in social connections, investing time and energy in those around us in order to hold on to love. 

Religious communities—diminishing on the Canadian landscape—hold on to something valuable. They hold on to love in response to hope rather than uncertainty. Volf says: “Notwithstanding all appearances, rapacious time will not swallow us into nothingness; at the end of history God, who took on our finitude in Jesus Christ, will make our fragile flesh imperishable and restore true life to the redeemed, so that forever we may enjoy God and each other.”

Modern Western society could use more, rather than fewer, religious communities integrated into public mourning. Religious communities are invested in the care of the isolated, suffering and dying, motivated by love of neighbour and love of God. They hold on to love, always remembering that the fork remains on the table.

 Peter Jon Mitchell is senior researcher with Cardus.

Convivium means living together. Would you join us in continuing to open and extend the conversation? Do you know someone who would enjoy this article? Send it to them now. Do you have a response to something we've published? Let us know!

You'll also enjoy...

Living A Different Answer

Living A Different Answer

Father Deacon Andrew Bennett, director of Cardus Law, celebrates Christmas with hundreds of Millennials  who respond to old holiday questions with a new zeal for Truth

Believing in Cities

Believing in Cities

In this final text from the Cardus’ What Makes a Good City forum, Andrew Bennett for reviving the spirit of urbi et orbi – the city and the world – by which religious traditions have made beauty and comfort integral to our urban lives.

Cultivating A Culture of Fatherhood

Cultivating A Culture of Fatherhood

Involvement in faith communities helps support and encourage healthy fatherhood and family life, writes Cardus Family program director Peter Jon Mitchell. And our culture's veering away from these spaces is a risk.