×
Convivium was a project of Cardus 2011‑2022, and is preserved here for archival purposes.
Search
Search
Engagement > CatharsisEngagement > Catharsis

Engagement > Catharsis

That picture captures why protests against Enbridge's Line 9 pipeline—and many other protests against pipelines in North America—will fail in reaching their broader objective of preventing the shipment—and ultimately the extraction—of oil. That picture, with its collection of simple, everyday goods does more to undermine the protestors' cause than any number of arrests.

Brian Dijkema
3 minute read
@RosieSpec Rosie Grover 25 Jun: Protestors' supplies at #Enbridge pic.twitter.com/25yYifJ7Wv

That picture captures why protests against Enbridge's Line 9 pipeline—and many other protests against pipelines in North America—will fail in reaching their broader objective of preventing the shipment—and ultimately the extraction—of oil. That picture, with its collection of simple, everyday goods does more to undermine the protestors' cause than any number of arrests.

Why? Well, take a look at what's in the picture: a styrofoam cooler, plastic water jugs, oranges, a plastic and metal sign, garbage bags, a bag of chocolates, some hummus, Tupperware, a can of lemonade, a sports drink, a backpack, a Tim Horton's ten pack of coffee, and a camping chair. Did I miss anything? Oh yes, cut grass, duct tape, a steel sign, and a pipeline.

Every one of these things has two things in common: each is common, and each involves petroleum. If you doubt that claim, find out how plastic is made, where oranges come from, or whether the camping chair was made in China. The fact is even something as simple as a plastic dish of hummus is soaked with oil (and not just yummy EVO!). If you're reading this on a computer screen, you're implicated in big oil.

Like it or not, oil, and the infrastructure that brings it to us, is as much a part of everyday Canadian (and American, and European, and Asian, and, and . . .) life as a cup of Tim's. If the pipeline deserves protest, so does the drive-through, and so does the Trans-Canada highway.

Which is why, however sympathetic I might be to the cause of environmental protection, I can't help but feel that these protests are as much an exercise in catharsis as they are in effecting change.

This is not a screed against the environmental movement, nor does it suggest unmitigated support for unlimited extraction in Alberta or elsewhere. Catharsis, however great it feels, and however useless it might be in the world of policy change, often still points back to a bigger problem or a legitimate fear.

This is simply an encouragement to reconsider whether we want to continue spending as much time and media attention on cathartic acts such as these. Real protests, as Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr. showed, entail material sacrifice, and an articulated, embodied alternative. If you find that you cannot make those sacrifices—can anyone fully give up on oil, I wonder?—perhaps it's time to reconsider your approach. Rather than seeing Enbridge and other members of "big oil" as the enemy, perhaps they can be engaged. Instead of seeking to "stop the flow of Tar Sands oil" why not rely more on natural gas, which would significantly lower emissions?

@esoltas Evan Soltas 25 Jun: The case for a 'war on coal,' in one graph https://twitter.com/esoltas/status/349638519213404160/photo/1

Why not picket Best Buy next Boxing Day with signs that ask "Do you really need that third big screen?" Why not focus on ensuring that pipelines be as safe as possible? Why not grow a garden?

It might be more work, you might not feel as good about yourself, but you're likely to get a lot more done.

You'll also enjoy...

What Lies Beneath Public Discourse

What Lies Beneath Public Discourse

Water treatment plants might not be about heaven and hell, but all political discourse—on hijabs or highways—plumbs the depths of human life ...

The Great Lie of Managerialism

The Great Lie of Managerialism

It's a huge and impossible lie, improbable to anyone who has ever witnessed to Satan's single great lie from the Old Testament: "Ye shall be as gods On the penultimate evening of 2012, I boarded a VIA train at Belleville, Ontario to make my way home to Montreal ...

Law Good, Virtue Better

Law Good, Virtue Better

The Prime Minister is Right Honourable; cabinet ministers are Honourable; the Senate is a house of Honour; Mayors are called Your Worship In this sense, our frustration with our politicians is less their adherence to the law, but more what we rightly see as a lack of political honour ...