Decadence and DeclineDecadence and Decline

Decadence and Decline


Brian Dijkema
2 minute read
Like Convivium? , our free weekly email newsletter.

Well, are we in decline or not? The question of whether the West is past its prime is suddenly all the rage among the chattering classes. It's gone so far as to make it into high-level meetings between the leaders of the Western world. Even Barack Obama, on his European tour, chimed in


. . . it has become fashionable in some quarters to question whether the rise of these nations will accompany the decline of American and European influence around the world. Perhaps, the argument goes, these nations represent the future, and the time for our leadership has passed. That argument is wrong. The time for our leadership is now.

  I suppose it would be tough, not to mention awkward, for the President of the United States—while touring Europe—to say anything else. Notably absent is any discussion of what decline actually means. No mention of the fact that the economic houses of the great Western powers and their citizens are teetering under the weight of previously unimaginable amounts of debt, while the

BRIC nations

eat away at the previously solid ground beneath their foundation. If the West's house is not in decline, it certainly is not on an incline. There is also little discussion—despite all the rhetoric about "values"—of the discipline and virtue needed to maintain the great institutions of the West. Both the West, and the up-and-comers like China are content to limit our discussions to the type of conversation you hear in a ninth-grade changeroom: who's GDP is bigger? Whose is growing more quickly? A case in point: the Guardian, which published the


on Obama's response to suggestions of the "inexorable decline" of the West, also ran a story on how Chinese prisons are

forcing prisoners to play computer games

. The prisoners are forced to win "virtual gold" in such games as World of Warcraft, so that the guards may then sell those credits for cold hard cash to gamers around the world. What an illustration! A nation which forces prisoners—many of them imprisoned for reasons of conscience rather than crime—to labour in front of a computer screen to aquire gold, which isn't even real, for gamers who want to cheat to get ahead in some banal game in the West. It would appear that whether you're on the decline like the West, or on the ascent like China, you're rotten to the core. Decline? Yes.

But that's been happening for some time now


You'll also enjoy...

Tut Holland!

Tut Holland!

In this case, the law proposed by the Party for Animals (click the link; I didn't believe it either) runs directly contrary to the religious food laws of Jews and Muslims in the Netherlands It's an interesting case study in how we conceive of progress these days, and it exposes a number of fault lin...

Turn your back to them

Turn your back to them

And so, the two greatest heroes of most nationalist movements—the peasant and the poet—both share a deep and abiding sense that the modern state is not real Is the Québécois quest for sovereignty a properly modest aspiration fuelled by evident injustices of Canadian federalism or a spiritually disto...

What the Monks of Tibhirine Teach Us about Faith and Public Life

What the Monks of Tibhirine Teach Us about Faith and Public Life

Of Gods and Men is a violent film, but it is so good because the conflict—the seed of drama—is not one between men with guns, but within the hearts of men who self-consciously exist to love God and love their neighbours, and they do so within an institution dedicated to that task ...

Join Convivium

Convivium means living together. Unlike many digital magazines, we haven’t put up a digital paywall. We want to keep the conversation regarding faith in our common and public life as open as possible.

Get a weekly wrap up of the latest articles delivered right to your inbox.